“The man who has a conscience suffers whilst acknowledging his sin. That is his punishment”…“Accept suffering and redeem yourself by it, that’s what you must do.”
-Fyodor Dostoyevsky
“The truth is you’re the weak. And I’m the tyranny of evil men. But I’m tryin’, Ringo. I’m tryin’ real hard to be the shepherd.”
-Jules Winnfield
“I’m sorry did I break your concentration?”
Pulp Fiction, by Quentin Tarantino and Roger Avery came out of the 1994 Cannes Film Festival as a controversial yet clear winner of the Golden Palm with its style and complex storytelling. Beyond its surface appeal, to which it has in spades, lies a profound exploration of redemption and the rush of catharsis which inevitability follows. Pulp Fiction takes us on a journey through concepts such as Aristotle’s idea of catharsis and Fyodor Dostoevsky’s perspective on redemption revealing the moral layers within the narrative.
“Trying to forget anything as intriguing as this would be an exercise in futility.”
Aristotle defined catharsis in Poetics as the purification of emotions like pity and fear through art. This is masterfully employed by Tarantino in Pulp Fiction and one could say is a main goal within all of his works. Pulp Fiction’s fragmented structure weaves together storylines that build up tension and emotional depth. This approach challenges viewers to piece the narrative fostering an immersive experience. Tarantino and Avery’s intricate storytelling evokes a range of intense emotions, from the ‘divine intervention’ shoot out scene, to the iconic scene of Vincent Vega stabbing Mia with the adrenaline, and finally the relief of her jolt back to life. These moments in the story help build up and then ultimately relieve the audience’s stress leaving them with a feeling of clarity and satisfaction.
“Just because you are a character doesn’t mean you have character.”
The film’s blend of humor, violence, and tension serves to engage viewers deeply, mirroring the emotional rollercoaster Aristotle described. The audience undergoes a purgation (cleansing of the soul) of tension, particularly through the characters’ arcs and the resolution of their chaotic lives. For instance, the transformative journey of Jules Winnfield, who unexpectedly seeks redemption after the near-death experience shoot out scene. This provides a cathartic release. As viewers witness his moral awakening and decision to abandon his violent ways, and then his subsequent unfortunate struggle thereafter, we as the audience want to see the character find his way toward redemption. It becomes a tense experience and a profound emotional release, fulfilling the Aristotelian ideal of catharsis.
“Pride only hurts, it never helps.”
Exploring themes of redemption, Fyodor Dostoevsky goes beyond Aristotles concept of catharsis to delve into existential depths. His narratives often depict characters undergoing transformations moving from decline to spiritual enlightenment.
In the movie Pulp Fiction Jules Winnfield symbolizes this journey towards redemption. Initially portrayed as a hitman deeply involved in violence and crime, Jules experiences a pivotal moment during a gunfight that he interprets as an act of divine intervention. This event triggers a shift in his beliefs leading him to reject his past and embark on a new path. Jules decision mirrors the moments of clarity and redemption found in Dostoevsky’s works akin to the awakenings experienced by characters like Raskolnikov in Crime and Punishment who seek salvation through suffering and moral reflection.
“You wanna play blind man, go walk with the Shepherd. Me, my eyes are wide open.”
The dynamic interplay between catharsis and redemption within Pulp Fiction weaves together a narrative that resonates emotionally and ethically with audiences. Tarantino’s clever blend of humor stylized violence and meaningful conversations not only captivates the viewers but also helps them on their own emotional journey. For example the films intense violence acts as a shock, to the audience and a way to release their fears and worries. The raw brutality of the violence compels viewers to face their feelings leading to an experience. At the time the moral dilemmas experienced by characters like Butch and Marsellus Wallace encourage contemplation on justice, integrity and redemption. Butch’s choice to rescue Marsellus despite their conflict is a gesture that reflects Dostoevskys examination of goodness within individuals.
_____
Conclusion
In this examination we can hopefully see how Pulp Fiction rises above typical genre boundaries to deliver a deep philosophical reflection on the process of emotional and moral change. Drawing inspiration from Aristotle and Dostoevsky we develop an understanding of the films capacity to emotional release and moral redemption solidifying its status as a timeless masterpiece in cinematic lore.
